SCROLL →
The Review That Wasn't

[caption id=“attachment_1237” align=“aligncenter” width=“642”]

11" x 14", Watercolor and graphite on paper, 2007. Courtesy of the artist.[/caption] A few weeks ago my friend Ryan Schneider and I were in Chelsea for the closing of _The Big Picture _at Priska Juschka. Ryan and Tom Sanford had curated the show of very large paintings from a group of painters who all embrace some aspect of the expressionist tradition. Well, not all. One female artist in the group painted much closer Tom’s comic realism than say, I don’t know, anything else in the show. (Apologies to Tom and Ryan, I early posted there was only one woman in the show. Actually, Liz Marcus, Holly Coulis, Emily Lambert, Colleen Asper and Lisa Sanditz had paintings in the show).While I respect Ryan and Tom, our tastes in painting tend to diverge from a shared sense of the absurd and bear little resemblance after that. Overall, I thought it was an interesting show. When Ryan told me that a New York Times fact checker had called the gallery, the show was all but certain to get a coveted Roberta Smith Friday Times review. Then, a funny and familiar thing happened. The review never ran. Maybe Ryan, Tom, and the gallery shouldn’t have asked for the review to be pushed back into September even if the show would closed during August. I mean, the point of a review isn’t really to drive foot traffic. It’s to legitimize the prices of work and give explicit permission to collectors to drop some cash. Ryan was pretty much crushed, and to add insult to injury, the Times ran that lovely ode to Gagosian and Dan Colen on the front page the day the review never ran. While, I’m not arguing that the Big Picture show should or should not have gotten a Times review (These guys are my friends), it was at some point in the pipe line for publication. Back in 2007, when I had my first solo show with Schroeder Romero, Holland Cotter dropped by on the last day of the show and while leafing through the press for the show said “I thought we covered this,” as he flipped through the book, clearly not seeing a NY Times review. Now, I have no idea who, if anyone, was actually going to write about the show, but I decided it had to have been Roberta. Why? In a small drawing in the show titled “What Not To Do” one of the directives was “Tell Jerry and Roberta to fuck off.” I like to believe that killed the review, somehow. To that end, I decided to write the review anyway. I’ve been thinking about this drawing since Ryan was nearly crushed by great expectations, and my friend @artlthr sent me this link to Dave Muller’s drawing “Smith” and “Re-Smith”. It made me feel old, but also vaguely justified in doing this in 2007. Nope, I don’t feel old and apparently Dave Muller was doing his Times review pieces decades ago. Way before I ever thought about it. Image: Art in Review, 11" x 14", Watercolor and graphite on paper, 2007. Courtesy of the artist.

The Review That Wasn't
All That Glitters Isn't Gold

Emily Falvey’s excellent

essay

that discusses my work. This text was first published in the Montreal contemporary art magazine esse arts + opinions, No. 69 Bling-Bling (Spring/Summer 2010).

All That Glitters Isn't Gold
Odds (#dancolenfail)

Image: Odds*, Graphite, colored pencil, and watercolor on paper. Courtesy of the artist and Artist of the Month Club. 2008. *#dancolenfail

Odds (#dancolenfail)
#carolvogel #dancolen: The Complete Essay
  1. @jmatthewriva you are awake, and i’m finished#areyouamonster?Fri Sep 10 2010 04:19:41 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to jmatthewriva
  1. Phillips de Pury Limps to the Finish With a $7 Million Totalhttp://nyti.ms/cILeI1so #carolvogel can write auctions and influence them?Fri Sep 10 2010 04:18:13 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Art Prices (and Mood) Inch Back Uphttp://nyti.ms/9z6dpe#carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 04:16:26 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Phillips de Pury Limps to the Finish With a $7 Million Totalhttp://nyti.ms/cILeI1 #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 04:12:03 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. xArt Prices (and Mood) Inch Back Up http://nyti.ms/9z6dpe#carolvoegel reporter, telling you what the art world buys like#dan colenFri Sep 10 2010 04:07:50 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Bronzino Is Given His Museum Moment http://nyti.ms/dx0tLI#carolvogel not @bravotv you fucking leechwhoreFri Sep 10 2010 04:06:23 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Playing Sculpture ‘I Spy’ in New York’s Cityscapehttp://nyti.ms/briYiBFri Sep 10 2010 04:04:59 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @jmatthewriva I am trying to unperplex, resolve the paradoxes, expect I’m a fucking idiot and that’s impossible. good luck with ur monsterFri Sep 10 2010 04:04:01 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to jmatthewriva
  1. New Prize To Honor Artists Under 35 ,http://bit.ly/cjWuq6#carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 04:00:54 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. A Record for Rembrandt http://nyti.ms/btbF5Y #carolvogel#recordFri Sep 10 2010 03:58:16 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Playing Sculpture ‘I Spy’ in New York’s Cityscapehttp://nyti.ms/briYiB #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 03:57:07 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. New Prize To Honor Artists Under 35 “the Jesus Award”http://bit.ly/cjWuq6 #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:56:26 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @jmatthewriva Go way back. This is about #carolvogelsucking #gagosian cockFri Sep 10 2010 03:55:11 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to jmatthewriva
  1. What Gagosian wants “A Record for Rembrandt” or Colenhttp://nyti.ms/btbF5Y #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:54:09 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. $13.5. Million for Self-Portrait http://nyti.ms/93ESM3 if that doesn’t suck, well you got #vogeledFri Sep 10 2010 03:52:47 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Reality Leaves a Fingerprint on the Biennialhttp://nyti.ms/aipMPR #carolvogel doesnt review shows, she re-reads press releasesFri Sep 10 2010 03:51:13 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. “hey man, i think you got vogeled on that deal."Fri Sep 10 2010 03:49:47 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Armory Shows Imperiled, While Other Fairs Adjusthttp://nyti.ms/aQ1FBB #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:48:32 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Casino Chief Is Said to Be Rembrandt’s New Ownerhttp://bit.ly/9V3Gf6 #carolvogel who could forget this.#dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 03:47:52 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @AntiPainter I drank the wat\er and bathed in #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:46:28 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. New hashtag for calling bullshit #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:45:25 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Casino Chief Is Said to Be Rembrandt’s New Ownerhttp://bit.ly/9V3Gf6 #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:44:55 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Sometimes #carolvogel compiles things…I will skip them. and fuck you #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 03:43:40 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @PAPILLIONART you can go to bed.Fri Sep 10 2010 03:42:30 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to PAPILLIONART
  1. ARTS, BRIEFLY; Michael Jackson Tribute Has Been Canceled She loves pop http://bit.ly/ah3b4W #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:42:15 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @FakeGagosian I give you this … ARTS, BRIEFLY; Contract for Theater Service Workershttp://bit.ly/9plVnU #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:41:31 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to FakeGagosian
  1. @rachelmatos his work is awful. Please feel free to repsond with your analysis. #colenblowsFri Sep 10 2010 03:39:54 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to rachelmatos
  1. Back to my dismantaling of #carolvogel When Famous Owners Sell Famous Paintings http://nyti.ms/94ldHp #carolvogelwhen you #failFri Sep 10 2010 03:38:19 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @FakeGagosian how’s the humidity in hell?Fri Sep 10 2010 03:36:17 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to FakeGagosian
  1. Soon You Can Hail an Artist as You Hail a Cabhttp://nyti.ms/9pIXEy Soon you can hail #carolvogel to write your featureFri Sep 10 2010 03:33:59 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Getty Museum Director to Leave Post This Monthhttp://nyti.ms/9FWTFO #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 03:32:25 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. In Los Angeles, an Urge to Purgehttp://nyti.ms/bTwZkr#carolvogel #dancolen sounds right #holegalleryFri Sep 10 2010 03:31:22 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. A Lady, Not by Leonardo, Retains an Expensive Allure not#dancolen http://nyti.ms/bhs22B #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:29:55 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. ARTS, BRIEFLY; New Chief To Be Named For Los Angeles Museum http://bit.ly/9nK39H #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:29:06 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Los Angeles Museum Taps Dealer as Directorhttp://nyti.ms/aimE4P #carolvogel #failFri Sep 10 2010 03:28:28 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Bringing Some Whimsy to Construction Siteshttp://nyti.ms/cZGq5O #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:27:34 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Metropolitan Museum Finds a Bald Manhttp://nyti.ms/c9XvkO #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 03:26:55 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. got shut down, for awhile. 3:25 amFri Sep 10 2010 03:25:58 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. oh, am I free? No, 2:17amFri Sep 10 2010 03:24:05 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Woman Collides With a Picasso http://nyti.ms/9DHWuj#carolvogel #value? A critic collides with a shitty artist?#dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 01:46:59 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @jaschaffer I’m ruining this thing to say something about it. This is not funny. It is awful. #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 01:45:30 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to jaschaffer
  1. Questions Over Fixing Torn Picasso http://nyti.ms/b3TQ9V I have questions over fixing a torn #dancolen at #gagosianFri Sep 10 2010 01:44:11 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @jaschaffer there only a few #instances available. For the rest, no rest.Fri Sep 10 2010 01:41:24 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to jaschaffer
  1. @j_d_hastings you are smart. Go unpack #dancolen#gagosian #carolvogel #nytimes #thefixisin #burnitFri Sep 10 2010 01:40:42 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to j_d_hastings
  1. @powhidaAsst You go in there and say “I am carrying gold. GOLD!” and show that shit to whatever proxy steps up#gogoisinparisFri Sep 10 2010 01:37:45 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to powhidaAsst
  1. @marzkim I have two consciences. We can’t say who you are talking to. I can’t. He won’t.Fri Sep 10 2010 01:35:50 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to marzkim
  1. @powhidaAsst you know we are sending them to our mole in LA. #gogoFri Sep 10 2010 01:33:22 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to powhidaAsst
  1. @jaschaffer Just know she is reporter doing Gagosian’s press for #dancolen. She writes about a living artist once in a hundred….Fri Sep 10 2010 01:31:48 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to jaschaffer
  1. Mona Lisa She Is Not, but Coveted Nonethelesshttp://nyti.ms/cFErEh #carolvogel er, #dancolen?Fri Sep 10 2010 01:30:31 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. At London Sale, a Giacometti Sets a Recordhttp://nyti.ms/9rXMBu #carolvogel she must be stoppedFri Sep 10 2010 01:29:43 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @jaschaffer Carol Vogel shouldn’t be writing the press release for Gagosian in the NY Times. I aim to show why.Fri Sep 10 2010 01:27:14 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to jaschaffer
  1. At London Sale, a Giacometti Sets a Recordhttp://nyti.ms/9rXMBu #carolvogel is helping Gagosian get#dancolen thereFri Sep 10 2010 01:26:25 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. INSIDE ART; O! Say, You Can Bid On a Johnshttp://bit.ly/dinwv0 #carolvogel art reporter #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 01:25:38 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Anyway, more #carolvogel From That Instant Thrill, Enduring Art, Now for Sale http://nyti.ms/9MB1HMFri Sep 10 2010 01:24:48 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. I whored myself a bit tonight. Team Gallery and Winkleman. the last was a closing. #3showsFri Sep 10 2010 01:24:11 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. So, if you’re just coming back from whoring yourself at openings. I mean to discredit #carolvogel and her bit on#dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 01:23:28 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @powhidaAsst Read the Times. Man, you are failing. Its about#dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 01:22:25 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to powhidaAsst
  1. @marzkim they should make you want to get gasoline, a knife, some rope, and a map of New York.Fri Sep 10 2010 01:20:41 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to marzkim
  1. See It, Feel It, Touch It, Climb It http://nyti.ms/bPFy4C Oh#carolvogel is this what you want to really say about#dancolen? I think soFri Sep 10 2010 01:19:35 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. The Torrent That Flowed in Picasso’s Final Yearshttp://nyti.ms/azvACb #carolvogel still connecting Picasso with #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 01:18:41 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @powhidaAsst Carol Vogel: an art world ass hugger.Fri Sep 10 2010 01:15:22 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to powhidaAsst
  1. Carol Vogel should not be writing about a living artist for a blue chip gallery period. PERIOD. We fucking #FAILFri Sep 10 2010 01:12:05 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @powhidaAsst Start spamming the world with the last#carolvogel articles you can find. I’m on page 8 of search returns.Fri Sep 10 2010 01:10:24 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to powhidaAsst
  1. The Torrent That Flowed in Picasso’s Final Yearshttp://nyti.ms/azvACb mmm, really? #carolvogel from Picasso to #dancolen for eternityFri Sep 10 2010 01:09:13 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. INSIDE ART; Blinky Palermo’s American Tourhttp://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9906EEDF103EF935A15751C0A9669D8B63&ref=carol_vogelFri Sep 10 2010 01:08:17 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Met Show Completes Its Set of Bronzinoshttp://nyti.ms/cBy9yb #carolvogel also writes about#dancolen today.Fri Sep 10 2010 01:06:59 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @artbystander you are in my way. #ragenotangerFri Sep 10 2010 01:06:15 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to artbystander
  1. Christie’s Wins Bid to Auction $150 Million Brody Collectionhttp://nyti.ms/90xBd3 #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 01:05:47 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @artbystander step down from the ladder my friend. Time is short. You know where to go. It’s not there.Fri Sep 10 2010 01:04:34 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to artbystander
  1. Just in case anyone missed she basically reports on art news and auctions. Maybe #Dancolen is a fucking product worthy of her words….Fri Sep 10 2010 01:03:07 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Back to my assault on Carol Vogel’s integrity. She should not be Gagosian’s PR whorelet. Not now, not ever. #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 01:02:22 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @artbystander We’ve never been in a club. Seriously. Shitty bars, yes. Club? No.Fri Sep 10 2010 01:01:09 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to artbystander
  1. Met Show Completes Its Set of Bronzinoshttp://nyti.ms/cBy9yb #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 01:00:03 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Christie’s Wins Bid to Auction $150 Million Brody Collectionhttp://nyti.ms/90xBd3 oh#carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:59:07 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. INSIDE ART; A U.S. Moment For Yves Kleinhttp://bit.ly/bgxzUF #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:58:23 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Maastricht Treasure Hunt Lures Collectorshttp://nyti.ms/bT4sD3 #carolvogel Not a Colen hunt?Fri Sep 10 2010 00:57:56 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @artbystander you’re one of the angriest people I know.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:57:06 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to artbystander
  1. @artbystander My anger is like your food. Right now, it fuels a close look at how awful art can be. #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:53:55 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to artbystander
  1. Ok, drunkheads. Hope you had a good night. Carol Vogel annointed Dan Colen with a NY Times feature. Just showing what she does normally.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:50:39 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. MUSEUMS SPECIAL SECTION; The New Guard Steps Uphttp://bit.ly/cFN2sF and critics like #carolvogel don’t.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:49:34 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. wow. Lloyd Webber’s Picasso Finally Set for Auctionhttp://nyti.ms/9DusdH #carolvogel maintains auction values#dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:48:57 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. What would Phillip say? A Conversation With Philippe de Montebello http://nyti.ms/cebMmr #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:48:17 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Planting a Johns ‘Flag’ in a Private Collection er, planting#dancolen in #gagosion http://nyti.ms/a6lZ6aFri Sep 10 2010 00:47:36 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Interlopers on the Skyline http://nyti.ms/9qDoJQ #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:46:57 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. J. M. W. Turner’s Last Rome Painting to Be Soldhttp://nyti.ms/9keYXf #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:44:38 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Rothko play review 2-Man Cast Shares Stage With a Vivid Character http://nyti.ms/bE9Dbo #carolvogel harsh critic#dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:44:02 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. INSIDE ART; Two Top Galleries Are One No More #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:43:01 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Met Will Finally Show a Picasso He Disownedhttp://nyti.ms/dl1bF9 #carolvogel writes about picasso alot. Now #dancolen!!! amazingFri Sep 10 2010 00:40:50 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. oooh, juicy Rift in Family as Whitney Plans a Second Homehttp://nyti.ms/bkaOwX #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:40:04 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Whitney Heads for the High Line http://nyti.ms/9y5Bml And more #carolvogel in depth reportingFri Sep 10 2010 00:39:21 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. After Repairs, a Picasso Returns http://nyti.ms/bpYtWX.#carolvogel That’s just crazy. Tell me more about Dan Colen. He’s like Picasso..Fri Sep 10 2010 00:38:23 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. A Jungle of Bamboo Is Growing Atop the Methttp://nyti.ms/b75UJL it’s not a review of a beloved piece, just press. #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:37:29 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. A Late Picasso Goes to Auction http://nyti.ms/9L7lEh did anyone have to write that? #carolvogel did. #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:36:18 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Tweaking a Name in Long Island City http://nyti.ms/9kqGYtoh, rebranding #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:35:32 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @black_von If I drew all the back doors, you wouldn’t be able to see the ground…Fri Sep 10 2010 00:34:49 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to black_von
  1. @Stottle There’s millions of dollars that make what I think and what you think about Colen’s work fucking irrelavent.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:34:13 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to Stottle
  1. The Blue-Chip Period http://bit.ly/bD5Qbn #carolvogel this is may favorite title yetFri Sep 10 2010 00:32:13 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. At $106.5 Million, a Picasso Sets an Auction Recordhttp://nyti.ms/8Y4EpY #carolvogel i feel sickFri Sep 10 2010 00:31:21 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. ARTSBEAT; A More Sober Follow-Up To a Record Auction Night http://bit.ly/bVFd25 #carolvogel you are #dancolen’s auction dateFri Sep 10 2010 00:30:46 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Emily Fisher Landau Pledges 367 Artworks to Whitneyhttp://nyti.ms/9MeWb0 #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:30:04 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Who loves an auction star? Manet Self-Portrait: New Star on the Block http://bit.ly/bggSxI #carolvogel does and she’s making one #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:29:34 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Aw sweet. At the Morgan, Gently Restoring A Treasure-Filled Building http://bit.ly/coZ8na #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:28:43 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. At Christie’s, a $28.6 Million Bid Sets a Record for Johnshttp://bit.ly/d9bgUw #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:28:04 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @black_von he did The Nest with his dead friend at Deitch.#hegotofftheshitFri Sep 10 2010 00:27:39 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to black_von
  1. Do you get what she does? At Christie’s, a $28.6 Million Bid Sets a Record for Johns http://bit.ly/d9bgUw #carolvogel#dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:26:37 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Warhol and Rothko Lead a Big Night at Sotheby’shttp://nyti.ms/bO3GnO #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:25:56 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Art Auction Highlights a Financial Downfallhttp://nyti.ms/aftUPC Why is she allowed to write about#dancolen#carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:25:28 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. INSIDE ART; Matthew Barney Series Now Has Two Homes Shocker. http://bit.ly/aRdx4L #carolvogel isn’t annointing#dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:24:42 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. The Ocean Blue as Art Abstract museum reporting…http://nyti.ms/cGU4hy #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:23:54 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @BLDProject sorry.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:23:04 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to BLDProject
  1. more reporting Motion Against Gallery Is Rejectedhttp://nyti.ms/atCOrB #carolvogel #nytimesFri Sep 10 2010 00:22:45 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @artlthr this is for everyone who thinks Gagosian is full of shit.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:22:14 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to artlthr
  1. On (Surprisingly Quiet) Parisian Night, a Picasso and a Matisse Go Out the Window more from the auction househttp://nyti.ms/d7ZebK #vogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:20:41 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @BLDProject you’re a bot or an idiot.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:19:17 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to BLDProject
  1. No, seriously… Michael Jackson Sleepover Tributehttp://nyti.ms/984SIZ #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:18:46 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Now, back to Carol Vogel, taste maker Lohan Avoids Arresthttp://nyti.ms/cdzFj7Fri Sep 10 2010 00:18:09 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @artlthr I have to do this. #dancolen is the worst thing about the art world and this article is the artworld at its worst.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:17:40 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to artlthr
  1. Serious criticism U2 Tour Thrown Off By Injury To Bonohttp://nyti.ms/du6ftO #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:16:18 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Whitney Museum Plans New Building Downtownhttp://nyti.ms/dlQ1YS #carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:15:35 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. But, this is about Carol Vogel writing a #nytimes press release for #gagosian gallery.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:15:07 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. I hate Dan Colen btw, worst artist of the aughts. Gagosian?! The silver man fucked up this time.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:14:11 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Funny. Phillips de Pury Wants to Make a Big Splashhttp://nyti.ms/cAP8yS #carolvogel is the only way #dancolenmakes the NYTIMESFri Sep 10 2010 00:13:13 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @hydeordie Carol Vogel, the art world reporter, wrote a feature on Dan Colen. Fuck this shit. She’s not a critic. This is an inside job.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:12:29 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to hydeordie
  1. Really?? Christie’s Alters Gallery Managementhttp://nyti.ms/b6w1t8 And Carol Vogel can write about an artist? #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:11:45 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Lehman Plans Auction of Its Modern Artworkshttp://nyti.ms/adnheN and Gagosian’s collectors plan auction of #dancolen Saturday.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:11:00 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Enclosing a Frick Portico Would Create a Galleryhttp://nyti.ms/aTdIWd Way better story than #dancolen#carolvogelFri Sep 10 2010 00:10:17 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. reporter. Guggenheim and YouTube Seek Budding Video Artists http://nyti.ms/97JO28 #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:09:29 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. !!! Business Is Brisk at Basel Art Fair http://nyti.ms/bbqnQY#carolvogel #dancolen and business will be frisk at Gagosian.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:08:49 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Even for Picasso, Bidding Stays Cautious in London Auctionshttp://bit.ly/duDRNy #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:07:08 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. So why is Carol Vogel really featuring Dan Colen? The art world is transparent.Fri Sep 10 2010 00:06:32 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. It’s back ARTS, BRIEFLY; Getty Buys Turner’s ‘Modern Rome’ For $44.9. Million http://bit.ly/acpl91#carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:05:12 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. I’ll wait. #fuckyou #NYtimesFri Sep 10 2010 00:03:47 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. http://nyti.ms/dAJFUZ The Carol Vogel search feed just stopped returning results. If you can get them, post them,Fri Sep 10 2010 00:02:01 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Manet Self-Portrait Sells at Low End of Estimates at Sotheby’shttp://nyti.ms/a4wGH3 #carolvogel #dancolenFri Sep 10 2010 00:00:18 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @Stottle It’s not a review its an auction booster #carolvogelNow go read the NY TimesThu Sep 09 2010 23:59:53 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to Stottle
  1. Auctions! Even for Picasso, Bidding Stays Cautious in London Auctions http://nyti.ms/cJG7OF #carolvogel loves #gagosianloves #dancolenThu Sep 09 2010 23:59:10 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @JHerbertArtist One thing at a time. This one has me apopleptic.Thu Sep 09 2010 23:58:24 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to JHerbertArtist
  1. more reporting Jean Nouvel and Wolfgang Tillmans at Serpentine http://nyti.ms/dBo30F #carolvogel #dancolen#gagosianThu Sep 09 2010 23:57:07 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Saatchi Says He’ll Give Britain His Gallery and Over $37 Million in Art http://bit.ly/az4SmD #carolvogel #dancolen #gagosianThu Sep 09 2010 23:56:24 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. INSIDE ART; Picasso Show In London Is a Family Affair (you think?) http://nyti.ms/cJG7OF #carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:55:52 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. ARTS, BRIEFLY; Getty Buys Turner’s ‘Modern Rome’ For $44.9. Million http://bit.ly/acpl91 #carolvogel #dancolenThu Sep 09 2010 23:55:10 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Well, she took a stab at Matisse…INSIDE ART; Fresh Perspective On Familiar Pop Master http://bit.ly/bF7N58 oh the inside #carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:54:34 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Electronic Insights Into Matisse’s Techniquehttp://nyti.ms/bFU3uE #carolvogel #nytimesThu Sep 09 2010 23:53:21 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. INSIDE ART; Cartoons Are Invading the Upper East Sidehttp://bit.ly/b2aYqu #carolvogel #dancolenThu Sep 09 2010 23:52:48 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. I’m going to spend the next few hours reposting all of#carolvogel’s articles to remind you she’s a high profile gossip columnist for Art.Thu Sep 09 2010 23:51:41 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. So Carol Vogel is the only hack at the #nytimes that Gagosian could get to feature Dan Colen. This feature is worse than mine.Thu Sep 09 2010 23:51:00 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Jury Selected for YouTube Play Videos http://nyti.ms/bn44d2#carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:49:15 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. A Town House for ‘Hedda Gabler’ http://nyti.ms/aqYpEb#carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:48:50 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Dressing Up a Construction Site http://nyti.ms/cUNnJ5#carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:48:20 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Berlin Gives Facelift to Moore Sculpturehttp://nyti.ms/9h4R37 #carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:47:38 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Peak Performances Announces New Seasonhttp://nyti.ms/byigYu #carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:47:06 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Hungary Is Sued Over Large Holocaust Art Claimhttp://nyti.ms/bnr6M0 #carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:46:39 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. @JHerbertArtist She’s the only writer working for the NY Times who would ever write a feature about Dan Colen for GagosianThu Sep 09 2010 23:46:15 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to JHerbertArtist
  1. @JHerbertArtist She is the whore of the rich and she just annointed Dan Colen in the NY Times.Thu Sep 09 2010 23:45:09 (EDT) via TweetDeck in reply to JHerbertArtist
  1. ‘New Photography 2010’ Coming to MoMAhttp://nyti.ms/9Robkt #carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:44:34 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. Boon For Broad Museum: Millions From Developershttp://nyti.ms/a7PKKs #carolvogelThu Sep 09 2010 23:44:04 (EDT) via TweetDeck
  1. At Cosmopolitan Resort in Las Vegas, Yoko’s on Viewhttp://nyti.ms/ah5u2C #carolvogel #dancolen11:43 PM Sep 9th via TweetDeck
  1. Tate Modern Expands, Despite Economy http://nyti.ms/cJr1L3#carolvogel11:42 PM Sep 9th via TweetDeck
  1. Art Team Represents U.S. at 2011 Venice Biennalehttp://nyti.ms/9GzMI9 #carolvogel11:42 PM Sep 9th via TweetDeck
  1. ‘Divine Comedy’ Exhibition at Sotheby’shttp://nyti.ms/9abbFK #carolvogel11:41 PM Sep 9th via TweetDeck
  1. Art Collection To Be Sold http://nyti.ms/cfW2Xd11:40 PM Sep 9th via TweetDeck
  1. Carol just wrote a long article about Dan Colen. Before you read it, let’s look at Carol Vogel’s history in the arts. You be the judge.11:39 PM Sep 9th via TweetDeck
  1. Now, twitter, pay attention. I am going to be here for awhile. Unfollow at any point. The subject is Carol Vogel.11:38 PM Sep 9th via TweetDeck
#carolvogel #dancolen: The Complete Essay
The Game

The goal of the game is relatively simple, get your work in to Met and make history.You need to follow a path through the art world from an MFA program towards recognition, representation, and museum exhibitions while picking up some supporters along the way who will help propel you into history.Like the real art world, whether your in or out is largely out of your control.We’ll assume you have some modest talent, but making history requires a lot of luck.The only decisions you have to make along the way are which paths to try to get ahead, whether or not to drink, and how you can best use your supporters influence to advance your career, the rest is either luck or chance, depending on your outlook on life. You can also play the ‘Bitter Version’ by following the suggestions for modifying the game play. Also, feel free to make your own supporters and new INS and OUTS. There’s at least 197 other collectors who matter and shit loads of ins and outs. Good luck.

The Game Play

  1. Determining the order of the players:
  2. Hottest player at the table selects their MFA program first
  3. Youngest player selects second
  4. Richest player selects third
  5. Meh. You’re in the game, loser.
  6. On the way to ®ecognition:
  7. Each player gets one per turn round.
  8. Advance your circle forward to the first circle on the path to representation. Roll one or two die to see whether your IN or OUT.You will either go forward, backward, lose turns, or in some cases, end up in New Jersey teaching.
  9. Note: Whoever starts at Pratt can take one “backdoor” roll before they leave the relative safety of grad school.
  10. Getting ®ecognition:
  11. The first player who advances to ‘®ecognition’ can roll 2 dice (or the sum of 3 single roles) to determine who their first supporter will be.You can roll for a CRITIC at this early stage of your ‘career’.You might get lucky and get a power card, but not all of them are that helpful.In fact, you might have to make a deal later on or get into a third museum.
  12. CRITIC Values:

1.Roberta Smith = 3, 5

2.Jerry Saltz = 4, 10, 7

3.Christian Viveros-Faune = 6, 11

4.James Kalm = 12, 8

5.Power Card: Hans Ulrich Obrist = 2

  1. AIM Program and Biennial Rolls: You can choose one shortcut roll to make when you reach ®ecognition, but not if you get sent back.
  2. NOTE: You can only call upon discretionary powers once per Game and you may use them immediately after determining your first supporter.Follow instructions for roll based bonuses.James Kalm’s power may be used each time another player gets into a museum, including the Met.
  3. From ‘®ecognition’ you need to choose a gallery to advance towards.Unlike real life, you cannot lose your recognition but outs can send you all the way back to the ® circle.If you want to play the “Bitter Version”, outs can send a player all the way back to the steps of their graduate schools.In real life it usually happens when you buddy up with a professor who does you a favor and gets you a job.
  4. Getting a Gallery: If the supporter is already occupied you can BEG the player to let you share the supporter or take the supporter with the closest numerical value.
  5. If you ever advance to a gallery, roll for your new supporter

i.COLLECTOR Values:

1.David Ganek = 2, 5

2.Aby Rosen = 3, 6, 9

3.Agnes Gund = 4, 7, 10

4.Peter Norton8, 12

5.Power Card: Larry Gagosian=11

  1. If you have gotten to Gavin Brown’s Enterprise you may make ONE poached roll when you arrive.If you get a 3 and a 4 you may advance to Gagosian Gallery.You may stay at Gavin Brown and take on Inside Job roll per turn if you’re a scumbag, but nobody will judge you I’m sure.
  2. Getting a Museum:
  3. If you somehow manage to advance to a museum before you pass out from doing shots, chugging beers, or doing lines off your iPhone, you may select your third supporter, a curator.

i.CURATOR Values:

1.Nancy Spector = 3, 5

2.Klaus Von Biesenbach = 4, 9

3.Richard Flood = 7, 11

4.Donna De Salvo = 10, 12

5.Power Card: Nicholas Bourriaud (BORE•ee•oh) = 2

  1. Getting into a second museum:
  2. It should be relatively easy to get into a second museum now that you’re an art star, or you decided to conquer the outer boroughs.You may indeed now roll for another supporter of your choosing.You have some power.
  3. NOTE: If you want to play the ‘bitter version’, you may continue to take over museums before anyone else can get to them and effectively win the game that way without ever getting into the Met.
  4. Getting into the Met:
  5. So you’ve done everything you’re supposed to do, right?You have recognition (or skipped it!), a gallery, at least two museums, and a critic, a collector, and a curator behind you, BUT there is no PATH to the Met.How do you get in and make history?I have no fucking idea.It’s really, really hard.In fact, you, the players, need to figure that out. Here’s a couple of suggestions.

i.Take a vote! Use a secret ballot andwrite IN or OUT on a little piece of Rail and throw them in a hat or something to determine if the player is worthy of making history.Hopefully, you have been nice to your fellow players and not belittled their futile attempts at negotiating the art world.

ii.Determine your own Auction Value by calling the value of a roll.You have a 1 in 6 shot of getting it right.You can try once per round.

iii.Fuck it, no one can stop you.You’ve won.Argue like hell with the other players that it’s the only fair way to end the game. Try and convince them the art world is really a fair, balanced, and reasonable place.

iv.Bribery.Divide up whatever cash you have and give it to the other players.

v.‘Bitter Version’ Don’t do anything.You’ll never know if you make history, because you’ll be dead.

Get a hole punch and make a bunch of little circles by punching holes in the Brooklyn Rail.Start with the Art Seen Section.You’ll need about twenty to play the game. Hopefully, you counted the number of steps you will have to take from each MFA program. James Kalm’s power may be used each time another player gets into a museum, including the Met. Image: The Game, graphite on paper, 2010. Courtesy of the artist The Brooklyn Rail

The Game